MedRiseStep 2 CK QBank

QBank › Practice questions › Suicidal ideation with a plan: disposition

Free Step 2 CK practice question

Suicidal ideation with a plan: disposition

An original MedRise vignette in the Step 2 CK style. Choose your answer first, then open the explanation.

A 45-year-old man comes to the office at the urging of his sister because of 6 weeks of depressed mood, insomnia with early morning awakening, loss of interest in his usual activities, poor concentration, and a 5-kg (11-lb) weight loss. He was laid off from his job 3 months ago and is divorced and lives alone. He drinks four beers most nights. He has no history of psychiatric treatment. When asked about thoughts of death, he says he has been thinking about shooting himself; he owns a handgun, and last week he wrote letters to his two children "in case something happens." He denies hallucinations. His pulse is 78/min and blood pressure is 128/82 mm Hg. Mental status examination shows psychomotor slowing, a constricted affect, and linear thought process. Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in management?

  1. Begin sertraline, ask his sister to remove the handgun, and follow up in 1 week
  2. Begin sertraline and schedule follow-up in 2 weeks
  3. Referral for weekly cognitive-behavioral therapy
  4. Admission to an inpatient psychiatric unit
  5. Electroconvulsive therapy
Show the answer and explanation

Correct answer: D. Admission to an inpatient psychiatric unit

This man has major depressive disorder with multiple high-risk features for suicide: male sex, middle age, recent job loss, living alone, alcohol use, and, most importantly, active suicidal ideation with a specific plan, access to a lethal means (firearm), and preparatory behavior (writing goodbye letters). Active ideation with plan, means, and preparation indicates imminent risk and requires immediate hospitalization to ensure safety, involuntarily if he refuses. Antidepressants and psychotherapy are the mainstays of treatment but take weeks to act and cannot be relied upon for safety in the outpatient setting. Means restriction is important but insufficient on its own when the patient has taken preparatory steps. ECT is reserved for severe, refractory, psychotic, or catatonic depression once the patient is in a safe setting.

Why each option is right or wrong

  1. Begin sertraline, ask his sister to remove the handgun, and follow up in 1 weekRemoving the gun is necessary but not sufficient after preparatory behavior; the patient needs a secured setting.
  2. Begin sertraline and schedule follow-up in 2 weeksStarting an SSRI is appropriate treatment but does not address imminent risk; outpatient follow-up alone is unsafe.
  3. Referral for weekly cognitive-behavioral therapyPsychotherapy is effective for depression but not an adequate response to imminent suicide risk.
  4. Admission to an inpatient psychiatric unitCorrect: active suicidal ideation with a plan, access to a firearm, and preparatory acts mandates inpatient admission.
  5. Electroconvulsive therapyECT is reserved for refractory, psychotic, or catatonic depression and is not the first step.

Suicidal ideation with a plan, access to means, and preparatory behavior requires immediate psychiatric hospitalization regardless of the patient's wishes.

References

  1. The suicidal patient (PubMed 9793545)
  2. Suicide Risk Assessment, Management, and Mitigation in the Emergency Setting (PMC10172543)

Missed it? Find out why.

Open this question in the QBank to work it with the Socratic tutor, or take the free Plateau Diagnostic to see which kind of mistake is behind your misses.

Practice in the QBank

More free practice questions

Why MedRise instead of another question bank

What you needTypical question bankMedRise QBank
Know why you missA percent correct by subjectAn Error Profile that shows which kind of mistake is behind your misses
Help on a hard questionA long explanation to readA Socratic AI tutor that asks until you can explain it yourself
DifficultyThe same set for everyoneAdaptive mode that gets harder as you improve
Trying itSign up or pay first20 free questions and a free Plateau Diagnostic, no account